Okay, so lately we’ve been talking about relaxing on your acne diet, repairing your unhealthy relationship with food, and healing the fearful emotions that are causing you to be so strict and scared about what you eat.
But the question is …. what happens if you actually do legitimately, and significantly break out every single time you indulge in unhealthy food?
I’m not talking about you just *thinking* you break out. When you put so much emphasis on your diet, it’s so easy to get paranoid and wrongly attribute a breakout you would have gotten anyway to this food or that food.
But for example if you have very clear skin as long as you eat a certain way, and it is completely obvious that you do in fact break out shortly after indulging in “unhealthy” food…
What do you do?
Well in my opinion, it may be caused by one of these three things (or a combination of them):
Stress Might Be Stealing Your Nutrients
Sorry to beat the whole “stress & acne” thing over your head like a dead fish, but how much are you freaking because you ate something you didn’t think you should have?
That acute stress attack could create acne on its own, so believe me, it’s much better for your skin and mental health if you just enjoy it when you indulge. If the nervous feelings start coming up, just acknowledge that they are there, but realize that they are not useful to you and don’t feed into them to the point where you get yourself into a frenzy.
You also need to look at the rest of your life and find ways to reduce your overall stress, and deal with the stress you can’t change in a more positive way. It’s also very important to learn to stop putting yourself down (not enough self love is a huge source of stress for us), as well as dealing with and processing old hurts and emotional traumas that you may have pushed deep down inside and never worked through.
You see, your body needs huge amounts of nutritional resources to process and create the chemicals and hormones it needs to get through stressful events. So for some people, they might find that they can have clear skin if they eat a totally “perfect” diet because they are getting enough nutrients to keep the skin clear + deal with all that stress effectively.
But the minute you fall off the wagon, you suddenly don’t have enough resources, and you break out.
You don’t want to live like that. So it’s really, really is important to work on the stress & emotional stuff because the less stressed you are, the more lenient you can be with your diet and still stay clear.
Your Diet Might Be Too Restrictive
Another thing that might be the problem is if your diet is too restrictive.
For example, some people find that when they eat a low carb diet, their acne clears up (and they’re thrilled). But then they have a bunch of carbs and their skin breaks out again.
Or maybe someone’s on a raw vegan diet, but then they eat cooked food again, and their skin breaks out.
As a result, they feel a bit trapped in that one diet.
This may be because you’re training your body to run on a certain set of foods and your body doesn’t really know what to do when you suddenly reintroduce those foods you stopped eating.
It’s kind of like … you know when vegetarians don’t eat meat for years and then when they eat it again, they get sick? It’s like that but with your skin.
Many people use that as validation that the food they were avoiding was bad for them. Maybe that’s true. I very well might be wrong about this whole point, or it’s just that everyone is different.
I can’t really say for sure, but I think in many cases it’s just because your body isn’t used to it anymore. But once it gets used to it again, it’s probably not going to cause any major freak outs.
Like if vegetarians keep eating meat after reintroducing it, soon it won’t make them feel sick anymore. And if it does, it’s probably more to do with the state of your digestion than anything (which is the next point).
That’s why I don’t tend to think that super restrictive diets that cut out many whole food groups are really the way to permanently clear skin. It’s better to eat a well rounded whole foods diet.
Diets that are very restrictive may clear your skin while you’re on them, but you don’t want to feel trapped in that diet forever. You want some leeway.
You Might Need to Strengthen Your Digestion
Another big thing with acne and food is how your digestion is (this may be the biggest thing, actually). Sometimes it’s not what you eat but how strong your digestion is.
So if you eat really good food that doesn’t set off any digestive distress, then you might be clear. But as soon as you go off a bit, your digestion can’t handle it and you end up breaking out.
So the trick to being able to eat a well rounded, whole foods diet, with plenty of leeway, is strengthening your digestive capabilities.
Now how do you do that?
It’s tricky because unfortunately sometimes the way to heal it is contradictory to what I’ve already been saying here (ie. relax a bit, and don’t eat such a restrictive diet).
Obviously it depends on how bad your digestion is. If you get mildish to moderate digestive symptoms sometimes – occasional constipation or diarrhea, occasional bloating, occasional mild heartburn, occasional gas, etc…
Then likely the answer is taking plenty of probiotics and fermented foods, drinking plenty of water (maybe with psyllium husk to help things along & sponge out the bad stuff), and maybe a short period of strictness like a three week candida cleanse to give your gut a break, kill some of the bad bacteria in there, and kick off a healthier bacterial balance.
You may also consider seeing a naturopath about getting a food sensitivity test, and strictly cut out foods you’re reacting to for a period of 6 or so weeks, while taking plenty of probiotics.
You could also have other issues like low stomach acid that could be contributing to the problem, in which case not drinking too much liquid with meals and supplementing with HCL betaine could help.
If you have serious digestive issues – reacting strongly to tons of foods, constant pain, bloating, gas, diarrhea, constipation, and / or heartburn (caused by something called severe leaky gut syndrome)… or if you have diagnoses with Colitis, Chrohn’s disease, SIBO, IBS, GERD, or other digestive diseases …. often the answer is a bit more long and complicated.
Unfortunately you may have to go through a period of strictness (several months to a couple of years) in order to heal this, on such a gut healing protocol like the Autoimmune Paleo Protocol, GAPS, or SCD diet.
Your therapy may also evolve into using things like colon hydrotherapy…. or even fecal transplant therapy (where they take the healthy bacteria from a healthy person’s poop and transplant that into your bum. Like probiotics on steroids. Yep, that’s a thing – a pretty gross, but apparently can be very effective if things are bad enough to warrant it)
Definitely suggest getting help with this from a licensed naturopath or professional to choose the best path for you.
httpvh://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvtrF0VePsQ
Okay. That is all. Do you have any stories, experiences, tips, or tricks on this topic? Share in the comments below!
14 Responses
Can you modify one of these diets to make it vegan? What diet option would be the best for a vegan? Do you know anything about internal hemorrhoids in the bowels? I’m trying to implement more fiber and drink more water but I think a lot of it is stress related. Natural lifestyle changes take time and persistence.
Hi Kathryn 🙂 I’m confused by your question.. modify which diets? Which ones are you talking about?
I’ve struggled with trying to find a realistic diet for my skin (and body/digestion) for years. I’ve tried so many diets my friends call me the “diet queen,” I’m always in search of a solution (through food) that will make me feel good and not make me break out. I could break down how each diet affected my skin but it’d be a hell of a comment. Yes, a low-carb, no sugar, gluten free, soy free, dairy free diet keeps my skin clear, but I’m STARVING, tired, frustrated and it just isn’t realistic long-term.
My acne is genetic and no diet (other than being generally healthy) will fix that permanently. To me, there is nothing worse than feeling like a freak for two reasons (breaking out and being on some crazy diet).
Hey Rachel…this was pretty much me about two years ago. I was soy-free, dairy-free, vegan, and avoiding about twelve other things because it was the only was I didn’t break out in massive cysts. It turned out I had leaky gut, and I had to do serious digestive repair with the help of a naturopath. But guess what…it worked. It took about a year and a lot of hard work, but it did. It’s not spam either. I comment on this blog all the time (probably too much lol) and now I can eat moderate amounts of most things without problems. Look into leaky gut as a possibility…this website and the internet in general are loaded with information on healing it.
But I totally get what you mean about feeling like a freak. I hated being “that person” on a crazy diet and having to worry about my skin all the time if my food so much as got even cross-contaminated. Starving all the time lost tons of weight, felt awkward…yeah. I remember all too well 🙁 You’re not alone, though, and there is hope to heal it. Hang in there.
Great article, Tracy. Wish you’d written it a couple years ago 😛 Love it!
It’s true. She’s not a spammer haha. Kit’s great 🙂 And she’s an awesome inspiration of someone who has overcome severe leaky gut / digestive issues (and the resulting severe acne triggered by it). Sounds like it was a rough road to healing it, but at least you know there is a light at the end of the tunnel Rachel. I know this stuff is really hard, but sending you love.
I am pretty sure that the GAPS diet would be good for me and my skin, but I’ve read about it and I just can’t handle something like that right now. I don’t have the time! I’m not sure I have another diet left in me either (especially not for a year) but thank you for the info, you are probably right I’m sure it would do me good.
Thanks Tracy, I’m kind of in that 90% clear range you talk about sometimes, I just don’t have it in me to go 100% 🙂
Hi Tracy,
A long time ago I bought your e-book about sourcing one’s passion, and creating a lifestyle that focuses on it. My partner, Joshua, works full time at a local health food store but hopes to make a change to work more intimately with nature. I’m currently not working and entertained the idea of starting a blog of my own centered on healing holistically, but focusing on many components of lifestyle. I was wondering though, how long did it take to become a full time blogger? How does one make a steady income? It would be amazing to hear your story 🙂
Love,
Mel
Hi Mel 🙂 That’s awesome, being able to help people through blogging for a living is amazing. It took me, I suppose about a year to start making a steady modest living from it, of course everyone’s situation is unique! Unfortunately all the details of how to do this for yourself are far too vast to discuss here, but … I do hope one day to create a second blog teaching people about how to do this. Although I haven’t done it yet because just one blog is a lot of work! haha one day.. don’t wait for me though, there’s tons of information on the internet already about how you can create an online business
Thanks Tracy, your article came at the perfect time!
The next day after you posted this, a friend invited me to have eggplant parmesean that was both home-made and home-grown.
It had sprinkling of bread crumbs and some mozzarella cheese on it. I have problems with both gluten and casein, and hadn’t had either of those foods in at least a couple months to a year because dairy especially triggers my acne. So I threw caution to the wind (sorta) and gave the top layer of cheese to my grateful friend leaving still two more layers of cheese and enjoyed! (Plus my friend was more than happy to share the burden of extra cheese).
Two days later, no acne! (The next day I had the usual gluten hangover… but that was gone by the evening and doesn’t leave a mark)
Thanks for the much-needed encouragement to take a risk!
That’s great Ann Marie!! 🙂 It sounds like your digestion has healed to the point where perhaps you aren’t so sensitive to those foods anymore!
I know this probably isn’t the correct post for this question, but since we brought it up, I don’t understand how the GAPS diet doesn’t make people break out more? Part of my hesitation is eating a bunch of eggs and nut butters is a lot of saturated fat usually makes me break out. It also doesn’t seem very healthy to be eating that much fat on a regular basis?
Hi Rachel 🙂
Everyone is different in what they react to, so I’m not saying that saturated fat doesn’t break you out if that’s your experience (although maybe it’s actually the eggs, and the nuts, and not that saturated fat that’s breaking you out?), but I normally would not say that fat in particular is something that is bad for you, or acne (unless the fat is damaged or rancid which is the case with fried foods, hydrogenated oils in processed foods, and most of the vegetable oils out there, like canola oil for example). In fact, I really encourage eating the right kind of fats (it’s really important for healthy hormones… stuff like coconut oil, grass fed eggs, avocados, the fat on grass fed meats, grass fed butter, salmon, etc), and I tend to include saturated fats in that… as far as my knowledge, saturated fat being bad for you has been pretty debunked. Don’t just take my word for it though, google around and come to your own conclusion about it.
Thanks for your reply! I trust your opinion, I peruse through your site a lot and it has been the only thing that has given me real solutions to acne that have worked so I really appreciate your feedback. It is actually a relief to hear that I (potentially) don’t need to be so scared of saturated fat, because if I can incorporate coconut, nuts and eggs into my diet (barring a sensitivity) it would make my life a lot easier!
I find this really interesting because it made me reflect alot on my own history of the diet/acne connection! Back when my acne was very severe I completely relied on my diet (which was very restrictive) to combat my stress and depression about my skin. It became such a hobby for me that even when I realised it wasn’t actually helping my skin, well not enough to justify my strict eating habits anyway, I still continued to eat this way because I was so invested in it as a hobby. These days I have a much healthier relationship with food and am clear-ish 90% of the time. Go figure? I can sympathize with people who take the diet route to an extreme when trying to combat acne but in the end I really believe it can do more harm than good. I always wondered why my friends who ate total crap could look better than me who ate 10 pounds of kale and carrots as snacks but now I realise the real effect that diet had on me. And it really wasn’t as positive as I thought.