
Okay, so you’ve been trying your hardest to cut out processed foods from your diet.
You’ve been heading to the produce aisle and avoiding the centre of the grocery store. If you do venture that way for a few items, you are checking ingredient labels like crazy. You know that most food preservatives, additives, sugars, dyes, artificial flavors and colors aren’t healthy and should be avoided.
You feel like you’ve finally got a handle on what’s healthy and what’s not in the world of boxed foods.
Well, maybe not. And here’s why.
Scan to the bottom of the list on an item that appears to be fairly healthy and without too many weird additives. What do you see there?
That sweet, innocent sounding, yet enigmatic ingredient lives there on the labels of practically all processed food items – the innocuous “Natural Flavor”. What does that even mean?
Unfortunately, natural flavor is anything but natural. It’s just another umbrella term used by the food industry to trick us into thinking we aren’t eating something bad when we actually are. The worst part is that natural flavor falls under some technicality which relieves the food industry from disclosing anything about what is actually contained within it.
Too bad because often the natural flavor contains more chemical ingredients than are listed on the food item itself.
Why They Are Allowed to Lie About Its “Naturalness”
The reason they are allowed to call it natural is because whatever it is that they derived it from was natural to begin with. Maybe it was a plant – maybe it was the fluid from a beaver’s sweat gland. If it started as natural, there is no need to mention how many horrible chemical processes that it went through before it made it’s way into your mouth… right?
Don’t feel bad – I’ve completely overlooked the ol natural flavor as guilt-free until now. Although I have to admit – I once, long ago, had someone tell me it that these silly additives were not as innocent as they looked and I decided to ignore the tip off.
But recently, my boyfriend and I have become big tea drinkers. Herbal tea that is (as caffeine is bad for stress and acne!), and we are always trying new brands, flavors, and medleys. Recently we came across two that we absolutely love called “Bengal Spice” and the other one is “Cinnamon Apple Spice”. The problem was that they were too delicious – usually tea is not naturally sweet, but these were just lap-it-up nectarous.
Suspiciously I looked at the ingredients again, and sure enough, it contained at least three different “natural flavors”. That old tip off I had received, long pushed to the back of my brain, jumped forward and I decided that this was fishy and needed to be investigated.
Sure enough – we’re suckers! The food industry strikes again – and they fool even the most health conscious of us by disguising these menaces with such cute names. We see artificial flavors, we put it back. We see natural flavors? Well it’s natural right?
What harm could it do?
If you do decide to consume some natural flavor once in a while… I’m sure you’ll be okay. We all consume some chemicals – it’s unavoidable in the 21st century. But the point is to not continue thinking these things are innocent and benign. The food industry would like us to stay ignorant at the benefit of their profits. Don’t let them fool you!




31 Responses
thanks for the article! have you found any worthy herbal teas then for healthy skin? I’m just drinking green tea at the moment (organic!)
Haha… I just stopped drinking them for now until I can look for better ones. Any organic herbal tea that doesn`t list natural flavours on it should be fine though! And green tea is good too… it has some caffeine, but there are a lot of health benefits to it
So true. The “Natural” label is such bullshit. Whenever I see something “natural” and then read the ingredients labels and it’s got more chemicals than a medicine cabinet I just roll my eyes.
I found out a while ago that even the brand of organic tea I buy has ‘natural flavor’ listed in some of it’s teas’ ingredients- particularly in flavors that are mixed: such as- white tea with peppermint, while peppermint on it’s own is fine. What I’ve started doing if I want the mixture of both is just mixing it myself!
I`ve noticed this too! it`s always the tea blends. I wonder why that is :/
I think it must be something to do with keeping the price of the product down, or something. It’s always something like :*White tea, *Peppermint (5%), Natural peppermint flavour. *Organically grown ingredient. or *White tea, natural flavouring, *Raspberry (1%). *Organically grown ingredient. So technically, they ARE putting in real organic peppermint/ raspberry, but I’m guessing it’s cheaper to throw in 1% of the real thing and then just add flavor 🙁
Laziness on their part.
To add to the last two comments, just read another source stating the National Organic Program (NOP) allows “Made with organic ingredients” to be used on any product with at least 70% organically produced ingredients.” I’m glad consumers are speaking up and sharing this information to make us aware about what we are truly buying. You’re helping take the fog out of the food labels :). I’ll be returning!
It’s astounding when we realize how much they get away with!!
WOW I used to drink that bengal spice tea like three times a day! HAhaha it is very delicious, I for some reason decided to stop drinking it about a month ago and drink some organic jasmine green tea instead or organic pepermint. Not sure if green tea is great either because of the little bit of caffine but since reading this, I think its better than the bengal spice XD
aahaha I know… it’s so good! damn Bengal Spice! I definitely think organic green tea has the step up on natural flavoured tea…. even though green tea has a little bit of caffeine, it has lots of benefits that seem to outweight the risk
LOL I just realised I’ve been drinking a Tulsi Rose tea and the last ingredient is “organic rose flavour” DAMN 😛 why do teas with flavour have to be so tasty?
BUT WAIT, it saysa organic? so how does this work? such a confusign oxymoron! so what to believe the organic part or the flavour part? shoot hahah
I know exactly what you mean. Grrr. Tulsi Rose was a fav too.
I found another replacement for that: Numi’s White Rose, and Republic of Tea’s Snow Rose. (Numi is always pure/no flavorings, but with Republic, you have to read each one, some are.)
I mean everythign in moderation, so a little bit of caffeine actually isnt bad for you, of course given too much of the healthiest thign can have dire health consequences. So in the end, i am a professional tea drinker! drink it 24/7! could be a big role in my acne due to watching one of your videos….. its har to avoid tea without there being a slight amount of caffeine its inevitable i guess. bit i just love tea! its a habit now, its in my cuture hard thing to do by gettign rid of it, i can cut back but are there any teas you suggest with little amounts of caffeine at least that woudl be alright? thnk you!
There’s all sorts of herbal teas out there with no caffeine that are just as nice!
I am drinking apple cinnamon tea right now that I’m going to toss down the drain. Once again the food industry trying to be sneaky, damn them!! Now I have to throw away bengal spice too, it was too good to be true. Glad people are getting word out.
Lol, I know…. Bengali Spice, damn you! It really was too good to be true.
I was just in India, now in Nepal. I cannot tolerate MSG or natural flavors. All the processed food there and in Nepal are the same as in America, loaded with chemicals and franken flavors. Obesity and cancers are rising rapidly in India. I swear the bulk powdered cinnamon I bought from the Indian go down mom and pop store had flavor added. Masala Chai I cannot drink there. Preloaded unlabeled…
Omg, I’m so upset. So I know this thread is old, and I sort of saw it as I was scanning your website. So I hit a natural food store after buying your book and Bengal Spice has been my favorite tea for quite a few years now. I double checked it, remembering I saw something about certain teas not being that great, but I figured nah, those ingredients all seem pretty natural. I”m so upset. I love the flavor! Guess I’ll stick to peppermint teas.
There’s lots of good teas out there; as far as mass produced teas: Numi, Teatulia, and Traditional Medicinals never use “flavors”… don’t give up 🙂
Guys – aweosme thread.. but just bought some White Tea with Pepermint infusion – and guess what… is had Pepermint Flavour!
Now I have to throw away a brand new box of really yum tea… 🙁
I know, they sneak them into everything!
Tracy,
Thank you for this important article. I’ve worked with tea producers for years now and find that the best tasting teas are the organic ones without any added flavours. Good, fresh tea is like fine wine and has layers upon layers of tasting notes. Generally, for flavoured tea, the freshness and quality don’t matter as much, as the flavouring overpowers the subtle notes inherent in the tea anyway. I wish people would start to appreciate fine unflavoured teas as they do good wine.
Great article. One of the most bothersome things I’ve encountered about “natural flavoring” is a food additive called “castoreum” (fluid from beaver anal glands) that is listed as “natural” in strawberry and raspberry drinks. Technically that is “natural haha but that just grosses me out!
Yep, it sounds pretty gross!! haha
The flavoured teas never tasted quite right. I quite like Yogi teas and similar spice teas, which use liquorice for sweetness and pepper, cinnamon, cardamom, etc. for the spiciness, and sometimes cocoa shells! With no natural flavourings, quite refreshing and some quite spicy, although they often need to be steeped for 5 minutes or more, so it’s good to have an insulated mug or thermos bottle.
“natural flavoring” is a food additive called “castoreum” (fluid from beaver anal glands. That makes me furious. How can we trust anybody? I don’t know what to drink!
Is ALL natural flavouring that? I thought that was just an extreme example of what it could be
That’s just one additive classified GRAS by the FDA. Its completely ‘natural’, so why be furious?
Platonifying ‘organic’ or ‘natural’ into a box that means ‘good’ is going to be a mistake. There will never be a label on a box that means a product is 100% what you want it to be (or what you’ve been told you want it to be). I really doubt there is anything ‘wrong’ or ‘harmful’ about the flavorings Celestial Seasonings uses in their tea since there is zero credible evidence indicating harm- if there was, it would be removed off of the GRAS list. Just like castoreum, it may sound horrible but it has never been shown to be a harmful thing to ingest.
See here:
http://www.fda.gov/Food/IngredientsPackagingLabeling/GRAS/ucm2006850.htm